Dizzying Diesel: How Public Fleets are Coping With High Prices

Two different counties reveal their strategies to combat volatile diesel prices.

Although municipal fleet managers use many of the same tactics to cost effectively care for and deploy the right equipment for the job as private fleet managers do, there's one huge difference — the dollars municipal fleets have to work with are largely fixed because they depend heavily on taxes.

They cannot simply bid for and complete more work as a private fleet can in a high tide year where success lifts all boats.

Because the municipal budgets are often tighter, outside forces like spiking diesel prices can hurt more. 

I checked in with a couple of standout managers (former Construction Equipment/AEMP Fleet Masters winners) to find out how they've been dealing with the diesel dilemna.

"There have been no changes to operations, as we still need to provide services as a municipality," says Kevin Schlangen, CEM, fleet manager for Dakota County, Minnesota. "We still have to plow snow, maintain the roads, patrol the streets, and maintain the parks."

Routes and idling

Because the county has had telematics in place since 2005, it has been able to monitor and implement changes in routes and control idling.

"Idle reduction policies have been in place for decades through tracking and monthly reporting — we have a good system in place to hold user groups accountable," Schlangen says.

How idle time burns the bottom line

That knowledge also gets passed on for the future. "Good data with historical trends help in educating leadership and new staff on expectations, and it gives them tools to train current and new staff," Schlangen says.

Matthew Case, CEM, fleet division manager for Manatee County, Florida, points to effects beyond the year's budget.

“High diesel prices affect far more than the fuel budget," Case says. "For a public fleet, they influence the total cost of operating critical equipment, departmental charge-back rates, lifecycle decisions, and long-range capital planning.

"Our fleet supports essential County services, so the objective is not simply to reduce use — it is to ensure every gallon is used productively, and every asset is appropriately deployed," Case says.

Measures to cut costs

“Our response has focused on operational discipline: right-sizing equipment, reviewing low-utilization assets for reassignment, reducing unnecessary idle time, maintaining equipment to manufacturer standards, and using fleet data to improve deployment decisions," Case says.

"Preventive maintenance remains one of the most practical fuel-management tools available," Case says. "A properly maintained machine is more reliable, more efficient, and less likely to create costly downtime."

Higher prices can put pressure on budgets over and above the usual county or city wrangling. Schlangen says budget issues and cuts have made planning and forecasting a challenge.

"Pushing back some [equipment] replacements make it difficult to improve overall reduction in fuel consumption and also reductions in emissions," Schlangen says.

Communication has become a priority for Dakota County Fleet. "[That means] letting the senior leadership and elected officials know how it is impossible to reduce fuel consumption beyond what we have already done without replacement of older vehicles/equipment with new units that burn less or no unleaded or diesel fuel," he says.

“We've added multiple fuel providers to our contract structure," Case says. "This allows the county to evaluate both pricing and product availability, strengthen supply continuity, and pivot when market conditions or vendor capacity change."

According to Case, Manatee County Fleet Services projected fuel costs appropriately for FY26.

"Despite continued market volatility and global conflicts affecting supply and pricing, we were able to get ahead of anticipated price increases and provide accurate, timely projections to our CFO and financial-management teams," Case says. "That level of visibility is essential to managing risk, protecting departmental budgets, and maintaining uninterrupted support for critical county operations.”

Ripples for rates

How has the volatility affected equipment rates in the counties?

Dakota County is part of a fuel purchasing consortium with the State of Minnesota and 50 other municipalities in the Twin Cities’ metro area.

"With that program, there is a fixed fuel and spot fuel purchasing contract that runs for 12 months each year, from February 1 to January 31," Schlangen explains.

"We purchase 70% of our annual average use in the fixed program and the rest in the sport program. With these programs ,Dakota County is averaging $2.23 for unleaded and $2.87 for diesel fuel in 2026," Schlangen says. "So, there is little impact to the equipment rates this year because of these programs. 

"We will have to see what prices we can lock into for the next contract that ends in January 2027. The 2027 rates will have to be adjusted when we know what that amount is."

Case says the effects on rates vary by equipment class, utilization, and operating environment.

'We don't take a one-size-fits-all approach to rate adjustments," Case says. "Instead, we evaluate actual operating data by asset class to ensure our charge-back rates are transparent, defensible, and sufficient to sustain maintenance, replacement, and long-term fleet availability.”

Sustainability focus is unchanged

Both counties already have sustainability programs in place and report that volatile diesel prices have not accelerated their approaches.

“High fuel costs reinforce the value of efficiency, but our approach is grounded in operational practicality," Case says.

"We're focused on selecting the right equipment for the work, reducing idle time, improving preventive maintenance, using utilization data to avoid excess assets, and extending asset life where it is economically sound. Those steps reduce fuel use and cost while maintaining the reliability our operating departments require.”

In Minnesota, Schlangen reports that fuel prices have had no effect at all on Dakota County's sustainability program. 

"We continue to purchase units that have a return on investment and consider all types of power from clean biodiesel blends from B5 to B20, E10 unleaded, hybrid electric, plug-in hybrid electric and battery electric," Schlangen says.

"Dakota County has been implementing sustainability measures in Fleet for over 20 years with constant pilot programs to test new technology. Some new tech is a good fit, and others have challenges," Schlangen says. 

"For the new Dakota County Recycling Zone Plus that is under construction and will open in Q1 of 2027, we are going all battery electric on that site. The program will include Toyota forklifts, a Volvo loader with every attachment you can think of, including a snow blower, pickup, floor sweeper, and a walk-behind snow blower, and a side-by-side — there will be no petroleum on that site," Schlangen says.

"It will be a great test and the equipment will be used at other work sites, as we'll haul the equipment out at times to test cycle times and [evaluate] possible future purchases." 

About the Author

Frank Raczon

Frank Raczon

Frank Raczon has influenced and covered the equipment industry for 35 years, including 15 years as senior editor of Construction Equipment, and marketing, advertising, and public relations work for the industry's top manufacturers. He authored "Caterpillar: Modern Earthmoving Marvels" (Motorbooks, 2015), and has won numerous awards in his career, highlighted by nods from the Construction Writers Association, the Association of Equipment Manufacturers, the Business Marketing Association, and BtoB magazine. Raczon has also won awards from publishing peer groups such as ASBPE and TABPI.

Sign up for our eNewsletters
Get the latest news and updates